I need to start out with a warning. These are SWEET. I think I’ve gotten my tastebuds used to not having sugar very often because these were crazy sweet to me. Which is really weird for me since I used to pretty much live off cookies
I would consider reducing the sugar but then I don’t think the recipe would work. But in a way, I love that these are really sweet and fudgy and satisfying because then I really only want one(or even half of one because they’re massive!) with a big glass of milk. Don’t bother trying to cut the recipe down though, they freeze really well so save a few out and freeze the rest if you want.
I’ll admit, I feel a little bad going crazy with cookie recipes lately. I know I don’t do well on a bunch of sugar, and I doubt anyone else does either. I mainly started this blog to post healthier recipes and I wouldn’t consider these healthy even though they have no added butter or oil in it. I even have a couple more cookie recipes I’m debating posting in the next week and a half, but I’ll see. I really believe there should always be “treats” but also that they should be treats and just enjoyed once in a while. This really is the time of year for treats, so I may just post another cookie recipe before I get back to some more nutritious recipes, if that’s alright with you
Chocolate Puddle Cookies
Yields 18 huge cookies
Slightly adapted from 101 Cookbooks Puddle Cookies
- 3 C mixed nuts, toasted and cooled(I used a mixture of pecans, walnuts and almonds. The original recipe calls for all walnuts)
- 4 C powdered sugar
- 1/2 C plus 3 tbsp unsweetened cocoa powder
- scant 1/2 tsp fine sea salt
- 4 large egg whites, room temperature
- 1 tbsp good quality vanilla extract
To toast your nuts, preheat your oven to 350 degrees. While your oven is heating, roughly chop your nuts and place on a rimmed baking sheet. Place in a hot oven for about 15 minutes or until fragrant. Be sure to toss the nuts a couple times to make sure that they’re toasted evenly.
For the cookies, preheat your oven to 320 degrees and place your racks in the top and bottom thirds of the oven. Line 3 sheets with parchment paper and set aside(or you can use one pan more than once). In a medium sized bowl add the egg whites and beat to break them up slightly. Sift in the powdered sugar and add the vanilla, salt and cocoa powder. Mix well with a large spoon. When fully combined, stir in the cooled nuts.
Measure out two tbsp of “dough” per cookie and place 6 cookies per sheet, no more! These will really expand. Place the baking sheets in the top and bottom thirds of the oven and bake for 12-15 minutes until they puff up and the top gets cracked. Be careful not to under-bake as they wont hold together and be careful not to over-bake as they get crunchy instead of crisp and fudgy how they should be. To cool, slide the parchment paper directly onto a cooling rack and then remove the cookies only once they’re completely cool. Store in an airtight container on the counter for up to a week or in the freezer for much longer.





















{ 26 comments… read them below or add one }
Ummmm these look DELICIOUS. ^_^ Sometimes you need something super sweet, ya know?
Absolutely! ^_-
I’m sure these are fantastic. They look so chocolate-y. My husband would be so happy if I made these. I’ll have to save this recipe for a time when I need a special treat to make him.
Maryea @ Happy Healthy Mama recently posted..No bake chocolate peppermint balls
There’s definitely nothing wrong with a cookie every now and then and these look so delicious!
Kathryn recently posted..eating in washington dc
In the big scheme of cookies, these are not *that* bad for you, in moderation. Ok, yes, there’s loads of sugar. But a handful of nuts are good for you and fill you up. Then, the chocolate is unsweetened… and the eggs are just the whites. Truly, I can think of way worse “treats” (like, ahem, the *really* not good for you cupcakes I posted that you commented on earlier! ha!)
Nicole @ Wonderful Joy Ahead recently posted..Chocolate Ganache Filled Cupcakes with Vanilla Bean Buttercream Frosting
Very true, the amount of sugar is what bugs me I guess, but really they aren’t that bad. I think why I’m feeling guilty is because of how fast this batch was gone! And I only shared a couple of them! Lol!
My Boyfriend would be so in love with these cookies – especially with a big glass of almond milk!
Heather recently posted..maple molasses oatmeal boule
they look really goood! so soft but chewy at the same time
beti recently posted..German Chocolate Cake
I need 20 of those, please
So drool-worthy!
Kiran @ KiranTarun.com recently posted..Warm Acorn Squash Salad
These look so rich and dreamy!! with a big glass of cold milk-heaven!!
vianney recently posted..Homemade Corn Tortillas for the Holidays with Maseca
Oooooh…..shiny!!!!! These look so pretty and crispy and chewy and….yummy! Trying it! Gotta go find some chocolate now to take the edge off! thanks! ha ha!
Wow, these look great!
*Gushing comment alert* Your blog is AMAZING! Seriosly, your pics are gorgeous, your personality rocks, and, puddle cookies? Chocolate? You, my friend, rock.
Aw, thank you! You’re so sweet! You honestly made my day
How do you think these would hold up without the nuts? They look delicious, but I have some picky eaters who are not fans of nuts. Also, I’m assuming these are considered gluten free? This might be a nice gift for my friends with gluten allergies.
Karen recently posted..Raspberry Baked Oatmeal
I have seen another version using coconut that you can find here. I haven’t tried them but they look delicious. I don’t think you can just leave the nuts out as they are a main part of the cookie but if you can find something else to replace them with, go for it!
Has anyone tried preparing this using an egg substitute? I have found one that doesn’t include any egg (duh), gluten or flax, but I haven’t used it yet and I don’t know if it would be appropriate to use in replacing egg whites. Any input welcome! I REALLY want home-baked cookies for Christmas, but when you can’t use any eggs, casein, gluten, flax or cashews (and I technically am playing it more loosely than I should with almonds), it gets complicated. Oh, cookies. I miss you so.
These have such a cool look to them!
That looks awesome!! Real treat for a chocoholic like me!! Lovely clicks..Soo Inviting:-)
Ramya recently posted..Dates and Sesame go-go balls
Is it just me or are these fabulous cookies look really shiny? I read the warning and I don’t mind that these goodies are SWEET. Sometimes, you just got to have to eat something really sweet just like your chocolate puddle cookies and experience a great deal of sugar rush.
I’ve been searching for a chocolate cookie recipe to try this season–something to balance out all the shortbread and rugelach. This sounds delish! And easy too. Thanks!
Bobbi recently posted..Mom’s Browned Butter Coconut Haystacks
These look fab and sound easy for a novice baker like me.
Debs @ The Spanish Wok recently posted..Chocolate Salami (salame al cioccolato)
Wow, those cookies look ridiculously good!
Sommer@ASpicyPerspective recently posted..POG Punch
Those look amazing! I bet they are so moist and chewy!!
Ari@ThE DiVa DiSh recently posted..A Few Random Monday Tidbits
They look amazing, what a lovely gloss coating they have!
Alli@peasepudding recently posted..Christmas Chocolate & Fruit Mince Pies
That’s crackly cookie top reminds me of a brownie!! I bet these are wonderful!
Brooke (Baking with Basil) recently posted..Caramel Party Mix